The Indian stock market is currently grappling with a significant downturn, marked by a notable decline in the BSE Sensex, which has plummeted nearly 10,000 points from its historical peak by February 2024. This steep fall has pushed the market into what analysts deem a technical bear marketThe challenges the market faces are multifaceted, including the withdrawal of foreign investments, an extensive valuation bubble, regulatory inefficiencies, and a general erosion of trust among retail investors.

As of February 2024, the benchmark index remains around the 76,000 point mark, a stark contrast to the historical high of 85,978 points recorded in September 2024. More alarmingly, small-cap and mid-cap indices have witnessed declines exceeding 20%, evidencing a broader market malaiseThe withdrawal of foreign capital has exacerbated the situation, with net outflows surpassing ₹99.2 billion (approximately $11.4 billion) between January and February of 2024. This trend is indicative of investor sentiment turning sour as global market dynamics shift.

The Indian stock market had enjoyed a wave of support from domestic mutual funds in recent years, with assets under management exceeding ₹50 trillionThe Systematic Investment Plan (SIP) strategy introduced by these funds was particularly popular among retail investors looking to ease their way into equitiesHowever, with a sudden influx of about 140 million new retail investors during the pandemic—many of whom are young and inexperienced—the current landscape reveals a grim realityMany are now faced with account losses of around 10% to 30%. The sharp drop in the small-cap index has significantly impacted retail investors who entered the market through SIPs, resulting in a considerable depletion of household savings.

The emotional toll is palpable; risky financial decisions made during the boom years are beginning to backfireFor instance, Rajesh, a Mumbai-based stock analyst, noted, "Many young individuals mortgaged their properties to leverage their investments, and now they cannot even manage the interest payments." This financial distress is only the beginning, as the pressures of account redemptions could instigate a cascading effect, further driving down market prices in a vicious cycle.

Moreover, the ramifications of this market turbulence are extending beyond individual investors

Advertisements

With the rise of Narendra Modi's 'Space India' initiative and the encouragement of private capital in the aerospace sector, skepticism has emerged regarding the valuations of IPOs from marquee companies like Skyroot AerospaceFurthermore, the plummeting family wealth may dampen consumption, with 7% of retail credit already linked to securities-backed loans, indicating a significant correlation between market performance and consumer confidence.

Global fund managers and institutional investors believe that the Indian market currently lacks the necessary catalysts to alter its downward trajectoryRecent key events, such as budget announcements and potential interest rate cuts, have already occurred with little to no effectEven at present levels, the valuation of Indian stocks appears high compared to intrinsic valuesThere may be select opportunities for profit at the individual stock level, but absent major positive developments, the prevailing downward trend could persist for several months.

On another front, regulators in India are engaged in a cat-and-mouse game with social media influencers who dispense investment adviceOn February 8, 2024, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) took action against six individuals, including self-styled investing guru Asmita Patel, prohibiting them from trading in the Indian stock marketThey are also seeking to seize ₹530 million of their illicit earningsThis regulatory blitz is a response to the rapid transformation in market participation over recent years, as retail involvement surged, leading to a proliferation of so-called 'investment masters' promoting stock market insights through social media.

Patel’s team, operating a dubious investment advisory, exploited exaggerated profit claims to entice clients, charging them hefty fees under the guise of delivering indispensable trading educationThe crackdown on such malpractices unveils a dark underbelly of illegal investment advice rife in India’s financial landscape, reflecting the exploitation of inexperienced investors by self-proclaimed financial wizards

Advertisements

Some of these influencers are known to command as much as ₹1 million for purported strategies that are often outdated and misleading.

Recent investigations reveal that such scams in the past three years have often involved amounts averaging ₹230 million, with a staggering 85% of victims being novice investors aged between 25 and 35. SEBI has previously mandated that registered financial consultants disclose their social media activities every six monthsHowever, despite these measures, the effectiveness of such governance remains in question, as over 42,000 stock market mentor channels actively circulate on social media, with merely 15% complying with regulatory standards.

Moreover, in the investigation into Patel's operations, SEBI uncovered that key evidence was stored in encrypted messaging platforms like WhatsApp and TelegramHowever, these platforms have denied compliance with the regulatory requests, citing legal limitations regarding data sharingOn February 3, 2024, SEBI reiterated its frustrations over the inadequacies of legal power to access such vital communication records during investigations of market violations.

This power imbalance has glaring implications, showcasing a regulatory system unable to keep pace with an evolving digital investment landscapeDespite India boasting the world’s fifth-largest stock market, its regulatory body lacks the authority to directly retrieve significant data from social media platforms—a critical tool in the fight against fraudulent activity.

Consequently, SEBI has recently made an urgent appeal to the government to amend existing laws, proposing a 'regulatory sandbox' that would empower them to command the removal of illegal content and access group data directlyThis marks the second such attempt by SEBI since 2022, but the proposal is facing dual resistanceTechnologically, Telegram has asserted that it cannot provide call data due to its architectural constraintsPolitically, there are apprehensions that granting SEBI such powers could lead to controversies and public discontent.

The proposal has also encountered fierce opposition from American tech giants, with Meta warning that it may set a 'dangerous precedent.' Additionally, as Prime Minister Modi embarks on a tour to strengthen tech collaborations with Western nations, enhancing domestic regulatory measures could seem misaligned with this agenda

Advertisements

Advertisements

Advertisements